The report says Higuain received a red card after allegedly holding a female referee’s hand after she asked him to let go on three occasions. He is also alleged to have made a sexist remark during the exchange.
The Professional Soccer Referees Association described the reported conduct as both physical abuse and sex-based abuse. That combination has raised the stakes beyond a standard touchline confrontation, particularly because the incident allegedly occurred after the match rather than during a heated in-game dispute.
MLS NEXT Pro reportedly imposed a two-match suspension and required Higuain to complete a restorative-practices programme. He has served the suspension but has not yet completed the sessions.
The union argues that the punishment does not match the minimum sanctions outlined in U.S. Soccer guidance:
The league’s reported position is that these sanctions are guidelines rather than automatic requirements. It says the incident was investigated and that the restorative process is designed to promote accountability, respect and repaired relationships.
Restorative work can have value, especially in a developmental competition where education is part of the structure. But the dispute highlights the need for a clear threshold when physical contact and discriminatory language are alleged together.
The Columbus Crew has reportedly accepted the league’s additional punishment and condemned conduct that conflicts with its stated values. The union, however, wants a sanction that sends a stronger message to coaches, players and officials.
The next storyline is whether Higuain completes the restorative programme and whether MLS NEXT Pro revisits its disciplinary framework. Consistency will matter as much as severity when the league faces its next serious incident involving an official.