For Everton, Johnson would appear to offer a different profile.
That matters for a side that has often needed more speed and unpredictability in the final third. Johnson has built his reputation on carrying the ball aggressively and arriving in dangerous positions quickly. If Everton are trying to become less static in attack, this is the kind of move that would fit.
From Crystal Palace’s side, McNeil would bring a contrasting set of qualities.
He is not the same runner as Johnson, but he can help a team hold its shape higher up the pitch and supply service to forwards. For a side looking to improve chance creation without losing work rate, McNeil would make sense as part of a broader refresh.
Swap deals are rare because they require both clubs to solve different problems at the same time. That is why this reported move stands out. Everton would be leaning into pace and penetration; Palace would be leaning into structure and service.
The next thing to watch is whether further details emerge around timing and squad roles. If the switch goes through as reported, attention will quickly turn to how fast Johnson settles at Everton and whether McNeil becomes a regular creative outlet for Palace.