The strongest defence of Ronaldo is simple: he has kept scoring.
Saudi football is still judged differently from Europe’s top leagues, and that skepticism is understandable. Rhythm, intensity and defensive quality are all fair parts of the discussion. But elite forwards are still judged on movement, finishing, fitness and availability. Ronaldo appears to have preserved those tools well into his 40s.
The more important test is not club football. It is Portugal.
That support matters because Martinez’s argument is performance-based. Ronaldo is not in the side because of reputation alone. He is still producing enough to justify the role, even if the role itself has evolved.
There is still a counterpoint. Ronaldo went scoreless across five matches at Euro 2024, and that tournament showed the limits of building too much around one veteran star. The issue is no longer whether he can contribute. It is whether Portugal can find the balance between using his goals and protecting the team’s fluency.
That will be the storyline to watch next: not whether Ronaldo belongs, but how far Portugal can go if he remains central when the World Cup arrives.