The headline number is 20 assists. That is the joint-highest return in a single Premier League season, putting Fernandes alongside names such as Thierry Henry and Kevin De Bruyne for pure chance creation.
That matters. Fernandes was not simply productive in flashes; he was central to United’s attacking identity across the campaign. Being the first United player to win the award since Nemanja Vidic in 2010-11 underlines how long the club has waited for a season of this individual control.
O'Reilly’s award is just as revealing. The 21-year-old reportedly became a regular at left-back while also operating in midfield, a level of tactical flexibility that fits neatly into Pep Guardiola’s demands.
Young-player awards often go to attackers with highlight-reel numbers. O'Reilly’s case appears broader: versatility, trust in big matches and decisive contributions when the pressure was highest.
These awards reward players who shaped outcomes in different ways. Fernandes drove a top-three finish through relentless creation. O'Reilly broke through by solving problems across the pitch and delivering in finals.
The next question is whether both can push on. Fernandes now carries that standard into United’s Champions League return, while O'Reilly looks set to be one of the most interesting names in City’s next tactical reshuffle.