Keane’s original assessment was blunt: on poor days, McGinn “parece jogador de pub”. Menzies accepted that the midfielder may not be the “mais naturalmente talentoso” player, but argued that his value comes from a more old-fashioned quality: relentless work.
That is a familiar description of McGinn. He brings energy, physicality and personality to midfield, qualities that can matter as much as pure technique when matches become tense. His importance to Villa has grown alongside the club’s European progress, while his influence for Scotland remains central.
Menzies’ broader point was simple: a player’s contribution should not be dismissed because it is not always elegant.
McGinn is heading into the World Cup with Scotland after helping Villa achieve a major European triumph, giving the midfielder a strong platform before the national team’s campaign.
For Scotland, his fitness and form could be crucial. The team will need both discipline and aggression to compete on the biggest stage, and McGinn’s ability to carry responsibility in midfield makes him one of the country’s key figures.
Menzies also believes football will command more attention in Scotland than darts this summer, even though his own tournament is approaching.
Menzies is preparing for his darts competition this week and joked about the possibility of a perfect Scottish season. He spoke of “fazer a dobradinha” - completing the double - before humorously suggesting cricket could be next.
He also believes a strong darts run might inspire Scotland’s footballers, some of whom reportedly play the game around the dressing room.
The next test will come on two fronts: McGinn must turn the noise into performances for Scotland, while Menzies will try to make his own mark at the oche.