United’s left-back position remains an area for succession planning, with Luke Shaw’s contract situation reportedly part of the wider discussion. Hall offers a younger option who has experience across the back line.
That flexibility could appeal to United, particularly as modern full-backs are increasingly expected to cover multiple positions during matches.
The report says Hall’s summer has been shaped by selection calls at both club and international level. He was reportedly used at right-back for Newcastle’s draw with Nottingham Forest before being omitted from Thomas Tuchel’s England squad.
Newcastle deny that there has been a breakdown between Hall and manager Eddie Howe. That distinction matters. Selection frustration does not automatically mean a player wants to leave, but United could view any uncertainty as an opportunity to test Newcastle’s resolve.
Hall’s situation also appears linked to wider squad planning. Newcastle are reportedly under pressure to manage their finances after missing out on European football, although the club would still have little reason to sell a young defender under a long-term contract.
There is also history between the clubs to consider. Newcastle have not sold a player to United since Andy Cole’s move in the 1990s, making negotiations potentially more complicated.
The next step will be whether reported interest becomes a formal approach. Hall’s role in Newcastle’s opening fixtures-and United’s decisions at left-back-could determine whether this remains a summer rumour or develops into a serious transfer storyline.