The discussions reportedly began with the appeal of signing a global star who could raise Cincinnati’s profile. Instead, the process has ended without an official proposal, leaving Neymar to reassess his options.
For Cincinnati, the setback adds to a difficult search for marquee attacking talent. For Neymar, it is a reminder that reputation alone cannot complete a transfer. The structure of the deal, the sporting project and the seriousness of the approach all appear to matter.
The report says Neymar has not rejected MLS altogether. He is reportedly still open to a move if the right opportunity emerges, particularly one that offers a convincing footballing role alongside the league’s growing international visibility.
The arrival of Lionel Messi at Inter Miami has helped make MLS more attractive to high-profile players, but Neymar would likely want more than a commercial spotlight. At this stage of his career, regular football, physical readiness and a clear role could be decisive.
Neymar’s current Santos agreement is reportedly due to run until the end of the year, leaving the Brazilian club with time to influence the next decision. He has previously made clear how strongly he feels about his boyhood side.
“2026 has arrived, and destiny could not be different,” Neymar said. “Santos is my place.”
The next transfer window will reveal whether that bond keeps him in Brazil or whether MLS can present the ideal proposal Cincinnati failed to deliver.