Tuchel has reportedly described Toney as a “specialist”, a label that risks narrowing the discussion around a forward whose game also includes hold-up play, physical presence and link-up ability.
The report says Toney accepts any role assigned by the manager, but wants his broader qualities recognised. That position is understandable: a striker can be useful before a penalty shootout, particularly when a team needs a target inside the box or an outlet under pressure.
His patience has already been tested. Toney reportedly had not appeared during the group stage before the final match against Panama in New Jersey. That limited involvement has made the “penalty-only” description easier to apply, even if it does not fully represent his profile.
The immediate obstacle is Harry Kane. The captain reportedly does not want to be rested against Panama, leaving Toney dependent on a tactical change, a late substitute appearance or an unexpected match situation.
The report also says neither Toney nor Ollie Watkins was introduced when England were searching for a goal against Ghana. That decision offered a clear indication of Tuchel’s current attacking hierarchy, with Kane remaining the central reference point.
For Toney, the argument must now be settled on the pitch. His previous experience of waiting for an opportunity before producing a strong scoring run gives him a personal reason to remain patient, but tournament football offers limited chances to change a manager’s view.
The Panama fixture is the obvious test. If Kane starts and plays deep into the match, Toney may again have to accept a supporting role. If Tuchel turns to him, even a short appearance could determine whether England see him as a penalty option-or as a striker capable of changing the game in open play.