Deeney’s argument is less about replacing O'Reilly after a poor tournament than finding the most suitable defender for one highly specific task. Messi’s movement into England’s left channel could force a choice between maintaining the team’s usual structure and assigning a player to track Argentina’s captain closely.
Spence’s pace and athleticism make him an obvious candidate for a defensive assignment that demands recovery speed. His ability to operate on either flank also gives England tactical flexibility if Messi repeatedly drifts inside or changes his starting position.
Man-marking Messi is never as simple as following him across the pitch. If Spence abandons the defensive line too readily, Argentina could open space for runners elsewhere. England would need midfield cover and clear instructions over when to track Messi and when to pass him on.
The report says Spence has featured throughout England’s campaign but has not been a regular starter. That lack of continuity could count against him, even if his physical profile appears well suited to the assignment.
Deeney also stressed that O'Reilly had not performed badly, but argued that “okay shouldn't be good enough” at this stage.
The next team sheet will reveal whether England favour tournament rhythm or a bespoke plan for Messi. If Spence starts, the spotlight will fall immediately on whether he can contain Argentina’s greatest threat without pulling England’s shape apart.