This one is confirmed: Chicago Fire have signed Gutman to a new contract that keeps the 29-year-old with the club through the 2028-29 campaign. Berhalter underlined the reasoning, saying, “He understands what it means to represent his hometown and takes great pride in doing so. His commitment to the club and professionalism are unwavering, and we are pleased to extend his contract.”
Gutman has been an important part of the group since returning to Chicago in December 2023, making 70 appearances across all competitions. He has featured in MLS, Leagues Cup and the US Open Cup, and he was part of the side that reached the MLS Cup Playoffs in 2025 - Chicago’s first postseason appearance since 2017.
There is a strong local thread here. Gutman’s connection to the club stretches back to the academy, where he scored in the Fire’s U-17/18 national championship-winning final. Keeping a Chicago-born player in a prominent role gives the squad a sense of continuity, particularly at a club that has been trying to build something more stable.
Just as important is the experience he brings. Gutman’s route has taken him from Celtic to Charlotte Independence, FC Cincinnati, Atlanta United, the New York Red Bulls and Colorado Rapids before returning home. That journey has given him a broad MLS education, plus the perspective of a player who has had to adapt at several stops.
The next step is simple: Gutman remains central to Chicago’s plans. With Berhalter clearly valuing both his consistency and his connection to the city, the defender appears set to stay a key figure as the Fire try to build on their recent progress rather than reset again.