England reportedly reached the last four after knockout victories over Mexico and Norway. Against Argentina in Atlanta, Anthony Gordon put England ahead in the 55th minute, but late goals from Enzo Fernandez and Lautaro Martinez ended their tournament.
The defeat will be central to the review. England had moved ahead against the reigning world champions, yet could not protect that advantage when the semi-final entered its decisive phase. The report says the result denied Tuchel’s side a place in the World Cup final.
England are also reported to have beaten France 6-4 in the third-place play-off. That result secured bronze and represented their best World Cup finish since 1966.
The scoreline captures both sides of the campaign. England demonstrated enough attacking quality to score six times in a high-stakes fixture, but conceding four will keep defensive control on the agenda. A semi-final defeat followed by a goals-heavy victory creates a mixed foundation for the FA’s assessment.
The advisory group is reportedly chaired by former footballer Jobi McAnuff and includes figures from sport, psychology, business and public service. Its broad membership should allow the review to examine more than the semi-final result, including preparation, in-game management and the pathway from tournament contender to finalist.
Tuchel’s meeting with the group is therefore an important next step rather than a verdict on his tenure. The report says his coaching staff and technical director John McDermott have already contributed to the internal process.
England’s upcoming Nations League schedule will now set the tone. Results in those four matches, and the lessons drawn from the Argentina defeat and France victory, will shape the next chapter of Tuchel’s reign.