Maresca’s first season at Chelsea pointed to a clear preference: Robert Sanchez was asked to build from the back even when errors followed. He became more pragmatic in his second campaign, but distribution remained central to the debate.
That matters at City, where the defence is already structured to play short from the goalkeeper. Trafford’s distribution is regarded as one of his strengths, giving Maresca a tactical reason to reassess a player whose role was largely limited to domestic cup football last season.
Donnarumma’s position is not vulnerable simply because a new manager has arrived. His saves were a major factor in keeping City in the title race, and he quickly moved ahead of Trafford after joining the squad.
That creates a practical dilemma for Maresca:
Trafford’s cup performances suggest readiness for more responsibility, but they do not prove he should displace Donnarumma. The Italian remains the benchmark.
Under Pep Guardiola, Trafford’s limited role would have pointed towards a departure. Maresca’s appointment changes the logic. Trafford now has a credible route back into contention, even if Donnarumma remains the incumbent.
The key storyline through the summer will be whether Manchester City keep two contrasting goalkeeper profiles or decide that one must move on. Maresca’s first training decisions and the club’s next transfer-window moves should reveal whether Trafford is being prepared for a larger role or positioned for another exit.