The exchange is playful, but it captures the complicated relationship many Irish supporters have with England during major tournaments. Premier League loyalties may cross borders, yet international football often brings old rivalries back to the surface.
Arlotte told Maguire she had already bought a ticket and ordered an England shirt for him. His refusal was delivered with enough force to make clear that, whatever his feelings about the match itself, wearing the shirt was not under consideration.
The prank quickly became recognisable as a classic football-couple dispute: one supporter chasing a shared experience, the other defending national allegiance.
For England, the tournament has started positively. Thomas Tuchel’s side opened with a 4-2 win over Croatia, giving Harry Kane’s team early momentum and putting them at the top of the group alongside their next opponents.
That result makes Maguire’s refusal even more timely. England are not merely preparing for another fixture; they are carrying the expectation that comes with a strong opening performance and renewed belief around the squad.
The next challenge is Ghana, with both teams level at the top of the group before their meeting on Tuesday. The match is scheduled for 21:00 at Boston Stadium.
Whether Maguire watches from the stands, from home or nowhere near an England shirt, the fixture will offer a sharper test than a prank call. England now need to turn an entertaining opening win into sustained tournament progress - while their Irish neighbours continue to enjoy the rivalry from a safe distance.