Carragher’s point appears to go beyond one signing or one rumour. The concern is the shape of the squad as a whole.
That matters because a bad transfer window is rarely judged on headline names alone. It is judged on fit, timing and whether the manager has the tools he needs. If the midfield still looks vulnerable, the criticism will only grow louder.
A difficult window can also be defined by uncertainty.
That is the tension. If Liverpool are trying to strengthen while also batting away interest in important attackers, the market can start to feel reactive rather than controlled.
For Andoni Iraola, if that report is accurate, the challenge is immediate. New managers need certainty. They need profiles that fit their game, and they need them early enough to build rhythm. If Liverpool spend the first stretch of the season still searching for balance, every draw and every shaky defensive moment will be folded back into this window.
The next few weeks now feel crucial. Whether Liverpool move decisively in the market - or simply settle on what they already have - will shape the next storyline just as much as the next fixture.