Carlos Baleba is reportedly set to miss the match while recovering from an ankle injury, meaning the midfielder will not make his Manchester United debut against his former club. His absence removes one of the evening’s most compelling storylines, but it also leaves United without a player expected to add energy and authority in midfield.
The report says Luke Shaw could return, although Carrick described his availability as “not clear-cut”. That uncertainty leaves United balancing the need to rotate with the pressure to field a side capable of setting the tie’s tone quickly.
United’s reported 1-0 home defeat by Manchester City has created frustration, particularly after a disputed offside decision in the build-up to the winning goal. Lisandro Martinez called the decision “unacceptable” and an “injustice”.
Carrick, however, wants the controversy to become fuel rather than a distraction. “We've had setbacks and they've bounced back particularly well and had some really good performances and good results,” he said.
That response must begin with intensity. Brighton are reportedly arriving after a 5-0 win at Coventry and have built a difficult recent record at Old Trafford, making this more than a routine cup assignment.
Carrick has stressed that winning trophies remains central to his role, particularly after United’s reported League Cup exit at Grimsby last season. The competition offers a direct route to silverware, but also a sharp test of squad depth and mentality.
With Baleba sidelined and Shaw’s status uncertain, United will need senior players to carry the night. The next storyline is whether Carrick’s squad can turn derby frustration into a convincing cup performance - and start building the winning habit he demands.