David Moyes is the leading candidate, with betting odds of 4/1. His case rests on experience, tournament credibility and a recent restoration of his reputation after difficult spells at Manchester United and Sunderland.
Moyes also has a European trophy on his résumé, having guided West Ham to the 2023 UEFA Conference League title. He is currently in his second spell at Everton, and his familiarity with British football could appeal to Scotland’s decision-makers.
The market’s message is clear: Scotland may prefer a manager capable of imposing structure quickly rather than an untested appointment.
Ange Postecoglou is close behind at 5/1 and would represent a more expansive alternative. His record includes five Scottish titles with Celtic, the 2015 Asian Cup with Australia and the Europa League with Tottenham last year.
Postecoglou’s knowledge of Scottish football is an advantage, while his international experience would suit a squad entering a transition. However, his short spell at Nottingham Forest means the appointment would carry its own questions about stability.
Other names in the conversation include Alex Neil, Steven Naismith, Steven Gerrard, Scott Brown and Steve Cooper. Naismith’s role as Clarke’s assistant could provide continuity, while Gerrard’s Scottish Premiership title with Rangers offers clear domestic pedigree.
Clarke leaves with the strongest longevity record in Scotland’s history: 81 games across seven years. Yet the finals record was one win in nine matches, with the team eliminated in the group stage at each tournament.
The next manager must refresh a squad that still relies on senior figures such as Andy Robertson and John McGinn, both now over 30, while preparing for Euro 2028, which Scotland will co-host. The appointment should define the next chapter well before that tournament arrives.