Cincinnati's 1-0 first-half advantage was answered by New York II's 1-0 second-period score, leaving the teams level at 1-1 after regulation. The 0-0 extra-time score kept the tie unresolved and sent the decision to a shootout. New York II converted five penalties to Cincinnati's three, the margin that settled the result.
The match highlights were concentrated in that sequence: an away lead at half-time, an equalizer after the break, no further goal in extra time and a shootout finish. The scoreline captures both phases - 1-1 across playing time and 5-3 in penalties - rather than a winner emerging during the match. Each side scored once before extra time, and neither added another goal.
Those are the key stats behind the result and the simplest summary of a contest decided after the teams could not be separated over the playing periods. New York II finished with the win; Cincinnati's first-half advantage proved insufficient. The difference came in the shootout, where the home side finished with two more successful penalties.