Right now, top-level women’s clubs in the U.S. rarely meet outside their own league structures.
That matters because the sport has expanded faster than its inter-league infrastructure. A deeper professional landscape usually creates demand for crossover competition. The men’s game has long had that outlet. The women’s side has not.
The main obstacle is not appetite. It is timing.
That mismatch is not a detail. It shapes player load, travel, roster registration and broadcast windows. It also explains why previous add-on events have struggled to find the right place. The Challenge Cup was scaled back, and the 2024 summer event involving Liga MX Femenil reportedly failed to build lasting momentum.
If the project moves forward, it may need to start small.
A compact format, limited entry and carefully chosen windows would be the sensible route. Trying to mirror the men’s open-cup model from day one could create more noise than value. The report also says the competition is not expected to carry the “Open Cup” name, which hints at a fresh structure rather than a copy.
The next storyline to watch is simple: whether league calendars move closer together - or whether organisers design a tournament tough enough to matter, but light enough to fit. Without that balance, 2028 will remain an ambition rather than a launch date.